Thermodynamics of sustainability, an introduction to natural resource valuation
Antonio Valero Capilla & Alicia Valero Delgado
CIRCE Institute, University of Zaragoza, Spain.
Topic O. Energy, materials, waste and water: Resources and footprints
Thermodynamics of sustainability, an introduction to natural resource valuation.
Ecological economists metaphorically allude to entropy to explain how humans are destroying natural resources of low entropy to convert them into waste of very high entropy. However, valuing natural resources in terms of [Energy/temperature] is hardly explanatory. Thermodynamicists, for their part, proposed the concept of exergy, but applied and developed it in the field of industrial energy systems.
Our hypothesis is that the exergy valuation of natural resources opens the way for Ecological Economics to bring Economics and Physics closer and connected. There are several reasons for this. The most important one is that by measuring resources and waste in exergies (in kWh, for example) it is possible to quantify the entropic generation, Sg, of any process, since the exergy loss or irreversibility is equal to the product T0Sg. But in exchange for what we have gained in interpretation, it is now necessary to define a dead state that really acts as an "attractor" at T0 , of the resources brought into play. If we are talking about natural resources, we will have to define a dead state referring to nature. Therefore, we define Thanatia as a possible state of planet Earth in which mineral deposits have been depleted and discarded materials become dispersed throughout the crust. In addition, all fossil fuels have been converted into CO2 and water, creating extreme climate change and a consequent high pollution of the planetary fresh waters.
The Thanatia theory allows to value the "abiotic" resources of the Planet, in terms of exergy content and their estimated exergy cost (rarity).
Lately, the theory has been extended to fertile soils in which it is also necessary to define an optimum soil consisting of an optimum of inorganic, organic and biological nutrients, which we call Pristinia. In such a way that all real fertile soil will be between Pristinia and Thanatia, and in which the different causes of degradation in any type of soil can be evaluated in kWh.
On the other hand, waste is harmful as long as it has uncontrolled exergy. It is therefore important to assess their impact on nature and to try to recover them using physical cost/benefit analyses.
In general, the thermodynamics of sustainability has the potential to evaluate the cost and impact on the natural environment in terms of entropy generated/exergy destroyed, which we call irreversibility. Ultimately, the rate of destruction of natural resources and the impact of waste caused by our civilization could be evaluated in kWh, beyond money as a unit of measurement.
Clear paths to teach exergy
Daniel Favrat
Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (energy center), Lausanne, Switzerland.
Topic B. Exergy-based analysis: Applications and teaching in academia.
Clear paths to teach exergy
This paper proposes a clear path to the exergy balance by subtracting the second Law balance (multiplied by Ta) to the first Law that let appear all the exergy terms. In each exergy terms it is shown that it is essential to clearly distinguish the process-dependent entities from the state functions and how the latter can be visualized in parametric representations including 3D. An opportunity is shown to superpose the various dead states (thermo-mechanical or physicochemical equilibrium). The typical First Law indicators (Effectiveness, coefficient of performance) are compared with the corresponding exergy efficiency for integrated processes including house heating with cogeneration and heat pumps or the valorization of LNG evaporation. From this strong basis the development of both First Law and Exergy efficiencies is shown for a variety of systems providing different energy services in the whole range of temperatures. A much greater coherence of the exergy approach for modern systems including co-or tri-generation is highlighted. The power of the notion of exergy efficiency is further illustrated by comparing various heating or air-conditioning energy systems in urban areas with the possibility to multiply the exergy efficiency of the subsystems to get a coherent ranking of the active technology options. Ultimately, we briefly show how one specific emerging platform (nolej) based on AI could simplify the work of teachers in thermodynamics in general.
Production and use of green hydrogen in the industrial sector
ANNA STOPPATO
University of Padova, Italy<BR>
Topic G. Fuels, combustion & gasification. Fuel cells. Hydrogen use in energy systems.
Production and use of green hydrogen in the industrial sector
In the future energy scenario that emerges between now and 2050, hydrogen will acquire an increasingly central role. Hydrogen is extremely versatile, and conventionally its role is that of an energy vector, but this definition is reductive: it can act as a fuel, as an accumulation system, or as a raw material. Its fields of application are many: from the energy sector to transport and industry. There are numerous methods for obtaining hydrogen, supported in recent years by growing investments, and these vary according to the raw material and energy source used. The focus will be given to the industrial sector.